Building Resilient Business Plans For Cleantech In Uncertain Times - Poornima Sharma
The emerging cleantech industry continues to face an uncertain future. We have witnessed policy shifts in the US through the OBBBA impacting IRA incentives, RFS and LCFS requirements, and bankruptcies among a few commercial-scale biofuels, green hydrogen, and other cleantech projects across the US and Europe. But there are positive signs too. The formation of investment alliances, such as the All Aboard Coalition, which are willing to fund “the scale-up stage” of new innovative technologies, to accelerate their journey towards commercialization, is very encouraging. Cleantech energy investment landscape may have slowed down in 2025, but serious and committed investors who believe in climate change can be found.
The critical question remains for innovators and founders of emission reduction technologies. — how to establish technical credibility, justify the commercial viability and bankability of their ideas, and assure lenders that their investment will be safe and profitable. A resilient and comprehensive business plan is a necessary step towards answering this question and a successful commercialization
Critical elements towards building a resilient business plan:
- Define the pathway to commercialization best suited for your specific technology, product characteristics, and financial conditions. As a Founder/Innovator, determine whether your preferred approach is to Build, Own, and Operate the commercial unit directly, or to be a Licensor of the technology, enabling project developers and oil majors to build and operate the larger capacity facilities.
-Recognize and acknowledge the complexity of the ecosystem surrounding the commercial-scale operations. Evaluate if the design and operation of your demonstration unit have generated sufficient data to meet the needs of each ecosystem stakeholder. For instance, determine what feedstock specifications the supplier can guarantee, including an acceptable variability range that should be tested during the demonstration phase operations. This understanding is crucial for assessing impacts on plant operations and product quality, and for developing comprehensive feedstock availability risk mitigation strategies that will satisfy future investors.
- Critically analyze the scaling requirements from the demonstration plant to the commercial-sized operations. Excessive scaling factors may not be acceptable to the design firm or the future investors. The inherent risks of a First-of-a-Kind (FOAK) design failures after scale-up, even when demonstrated well at a lower capacity, may influence liability-sharing arrangements between the founders/innovators and design firms. Investment firms typically demonstrate low tolerance for such risks
- Understand the requirements of the federal and state permitting process and requirements very early in the project. Identify the data that must be collected during the operation of the demonstration unit or developed by the design firm, to avoid missed opportunities that may delay the permitting process
- Offtake and Feedstock agreements are essential agreements that are fundamental pre-requisites for attracting investors. While these are generally put in place following successful results from the demonstration unit, conducting some early research to understand the quality and availability of feedstocks enables design flexibility to be built in. Similarly, understanding the product off-taker requirement is essential, particularly when continuous product availability must be guaranteed.
- Conduct capital investment sensitivity analysis to understand how capital investment requirements vary based on quality specifications, for instance, of utilities. Availability of low CI/green power/, blue or green hydrogen, or a design with a zero liquid emission requirement can impact capital investment, site selection of the commercial unit, and overall schedule for production at scale, product pricing, and overall project return rates
Numerous additional elements require careful review, analysis, and strategic business planning to address requirements and establish comprehensive risk mitigation protocols.
A specialized consulting firm such as GreenBridgeLLC is uniquely positioned to serve as a strategic thought partner, jointly developing comprehensive strategies and robust business plans that facilitate the transition from demonstration to commercial-scale operations.
The path from innovation to commercialization requires more than breakthrough technology — it demands strategic planning, risk management, and a deep understanding of the complex cleantech ecosystem. Success in today’s challenging environment depends on building resilience into every aspect of your commercialization strategy.
Connect with Poornima on LinkedIn.
